Metal: Difference between revisions

From Music 115 Watson Wiki backup
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Link to Spotify playlist: [https://open.spotify.com/playlist/7yPi0lahv5uOzUcWX8jDLv?si=62e36f910cd14428 Mus115 - 13. Metal]
----
'''Metal overview:''' to a lot of fans, Heavy Metal is a changeable term. Early Metal bands no longer qualify with our current understanding of Heavy Metal. But broadly speaking, Metal is louder, and "harder" (i.e., more distortion in the guitars, vocals, louder drums, more complications in rhythms, faster playing, repetitive riffs) and, lyrically, about hard topics like violence, suicide, rebellion, and anger. Basically rock with the soft edges removed.
'''Metal overview:''' to a lot of fans, Heavy Metal is a changeable term. Early Metal bands no longer qualify with our current understanding of Heavy Metal. But broadly speaking, Metal is louder, and "harder" (i.e., more distortion in the guitars, vocals, louder drums, more complications in rhythms, faster playing, repetitive riffs) and, lyrically, about hard topics like violence, suicide, rebellion, and anger. Basically rock with the soft edges removed.
'''Quasi-Metal'''


One of the first bands that started this or at least influenced many of the real metal bands to follow was Led Zeppelin. There is constant debate regarding if Led Zeppelin is actually metal or not. This is something to consider in the questions. Elements such as high-pitched vocal bordering on shouting, with lots of edge, heavy low-range guitar, lots of 16th note subdivisions, are definitely characteristics of metal, and can be found in 3 of the following 4 songs:
One of the first bands that started this or at least influenced many of the real metal bands to follow was Led Zeppelin. There is constant debate regarding if Led Zeppelin is actually metal or not. This is something to consider in the questions. Elements such as high-pitched vocal bordering on shouting, with lots of edge, heavy low-range guitar, lots of 16th note subdivisions, are definitely characteristics of metal, and can be found in 3 of the following 4 songs:
Line 7: Line 13:
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5v2vkoTamoisazJFanHJjk?si=392fbb3f14ae410b Kashmir]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5v2vkoTamoisazJFanHJjk?si=392fbb3f14ae410b Kashmir]


Their biggest hit is the least "metal" one of all:


Their biggest hit is the least "hard" one of all, Stairway to Heaven
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5CQ30WqJwcep0pYcV4AMNc?si=458e702009fe412e Stairway to Heaven] - a masterpiece of a song. It has a continual crescendo (getting louder) and accelerando (getting faster), which is a bit unusual. Most songs stay at about the same tempo, and while dynamic contrast is more prevalent, they generally don't build continually.
 
Links to an external site. (a masterpiece of a song), although it eventually gets there in the end. It has a continual crescendo (getting louder) and accelerando (getting faster), which is a bit unusual. Most songs are supposed to stay at about the same tempo.
 
Undeniable Metal


Black Sabbath and Ozzy Osborurne


Paranoid


Links to an external site.
'''Metal'''


Iron Man
Black Sabbath and Ozzy Osbourne


Links to an external site.
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/1Y373MqadDRtclJNdnUXVc?si=562e487fe5ab48a0 Paranoid]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3IOQZRcEkplCXg6LofKqE9?si=10813631e77c4d0c Iron Man]


After Ozzy split from Black Sabbath, he had great commercial success with hits like:
After Ozzy split from Black Sabbath, he had great commercial success with hits like:


Crazy Train
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/1Lm6B6aXsBhcsxrimyhkJb?si=061b3d3922d4490e Crazy Train]
 
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3RNr2r45BeYqLoZ42tj9fi?si=3c5bdaebd9be4f54 Rock 'n' Roll Rebel]
Links to an external site.


Rock 'n' Roll Rebel
In particular, Rock 'n' Roll Rebel is probably the most "metal" of these. Lyrically, we can see a great example of the metal ethos. Whereas Bob Dylan wrote "please get out of the new [road] / If you can't lend a hand" in his song "The Times, They Are a Changin' ", Ozzy wrote "Do what you will to try and make me conform / But I'll make you wish you had never been born". Yikes!


Links to an external site.
'''American Metal'''
 
In particular, Rock 'n' Roll Rebel is probably the most "metal" of these. Lyrically, we can see a great example of the metal ethos. Whereas Bob Dylan wrote "please get out of the new [road] / If you can't lend a hand" in his song "The Times, They Are a Changin'", Ozzy wrote "Do what you will to try and make me conform / But I'll make you wish you had never been born". Yikes!
 
American Metal


I'm skipping some bands like Steppenwolf and MC5, and straight to Alice Cooper.
I'm skipping some bands like Steppenwolf and MC5, and straight to Alice Cooper.
Line 44: Line 41:
Some hits:
Some hits:


School's Out
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5Z8EDau8uNcP1E8JvmfkZe?si=4141d28faf2e4031 School's Out]
 
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5D2eCwqbHcqOnfHOCM6TnV?si=4d23568284de4648 No More Mr. Nice Guy]
Links to an external site.
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/02WVK9TPtjSOcmy9cDkd5D?si=f4057004546f4193 Go to Hell] - (from Alice Cooper, once he went solo from the band Alice Cooper. Not confusing at all)
 
No More Mr. Nice Guy
 
Links to an external site.
 
Go to Hell
 
Links to an external site. (from Alice Cooper, once he went solo from the band Alice Cooper. Not confusing at all)
 
 
Van Halen
 
Another example where looking back from now, this band doesn't seem metal at all, but at the time, they were totally metal. They hit big with singer David Lee Roth from 1983 - 1986, and had continued success with Sammy Hagar in 1986-1996. This is a hot topic divide for some Van Halen fans - some consider the David Lee Roth Era as the "only" era, while others like Sammy better. One of the main things with the band is that Eddie Van Halen became the real star, with the release of "Eruption", a guitar only instrumental that featured double-tapping technique. This was not a new technique. In fact, I think there was video of Chuck Berry doing a little bit in his shows. But it was certainly the first to highlight, magnify, and popularize this technique. If you're not sure what this means, here's an explanation video: <nowiki>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWAi39zz1G0</nowiki>
 
Links to an external site.
 
Eruption
 
Links to an external site. (the double tapping starts around 2:30 in)
 
Jump
 
Links to an external site. (their first big hit)
 
Hot for Teacher
 
Links to an external site. (this is more metal, with the double-kick drumming and guitar distortions and fast licks)
 
Running with the Devil
 
Links to an external site.
 
Of course, one of Van Halen's biggest hits (especially with the Sammy Hagar years) is probably this song: "Right Now": <nowiki>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEI7cTBVr2A</nowiki>


Links to an external site.


(Audio only link
'''Van Halen'''


Links to an external site.)
Another example of a band where today, the songs don't seem metal at all (and fit more in 90s alternative style possibly), but at the time, they were absolutely considered metal. They hit big with singer David Lee Roth from 1983 - 1986, and had continued success with Sammy Hagar in 1986-1996. This is a hot topic divide for some Van Halen fans - some consider the David Lee Roth Era as the "only" era, while others like Sammy better. One of the main things with the band is that Eddie Van Halen became the real star, with the release of "Eruption", a guitar only instrumental that featured double-tapping technique. This was not a new technique. In fact, I think there was video of Chuck Berry doing a little bit in his shows. But it was certainly the first to highlight, magnify, and popularize this technique. If you're not sure what this means, here's an explanation video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWAi39zz1G0


This video ended up winning the MTV "Video of the Year" award in 1992 (when it was released). Here's a behind the scenes article about the creation and the video: The conflicted history of Sammy Hagar’s Van Halen smash “Right Now”: ‘It shows you what I know’
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3lW0MLws0srqqR3DRRPLZp?si=55a8bdae70b34e44 Eruption] - the double tapping starts around 0:55 in
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/6Fba9RZtC6vTY814JToDtP?si=e64ee11111644b54 Jump] - their first big hit, with 80s synth sounds
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/6QDbGdbJ57Mtkflsg42WV5?si=569996f24ba94972 Hot for Teacher] - this is more metal, with the double-kick drumming and guitar distortions and fast licks
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/46FW5ZZ6fOF1WpMTEOVEHX?si=48dd5bef489c43fa Running with the Devil]


Links to an external site.

Of course, one of Van Halen's biggest hits (especially in the Sammy Hagar years) is probably this song:


Guns N' Roses
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/6N1sNzq3CArC1pMSaZTxaT?si=accd1fdf16fa4d75 Right Now]


Early song Reckless Life
The [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gU7d2EHV_OQ video] ended up winning the MTV "Video of the Year" award in 1992 (when it was released). Here's a behind the scenes article about the creation and the video:


Links to an external site.
* [https://somethingelsereviews.com/2015/06/19/van-halen-right-now-sammy-hagar/ The conflicted history of Sammy Hagar’s Van Halen smash “Right Now”: ‘It shows you what I know’]


Welcome to the Jungle


Links to an external site.
'''Guns N' Roses'''


Sweet Child of Mine
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3lN4CAGBYeEj0QKG2NBylA?si=9b47ea0316e04b3c Reckless Life] - a very early song for Guns N'Roses.
 
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/0G21yYKMZoHa30cYVi1iA8?si=f459baeded5f477c Welcome to the Jungle]
Links to an external site.
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/7snQQk1zcKl8gZ92AnueZW?si=b8cffabd0f02407c Sweet Child of Mine]


and a rare acoustic, softer side:
and a rare acoustic, softer side:


Move to the City
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/2ZBTYxBJaCJdFNs7cJABIP?si=59c1d2e7f476492e Move to the City]
 
Links to an external site.
 
Metallica
 
Metallica is the archetypal heavy metal band of the mid 1980-s and 1990s. They achieved success with 1988s ...And Justic for All. They definitely took metal to harder extremes from previous bands, but also ended up softening up a tiny little as they got older with Load and ReLoad, then got harder again with St. Anger. To me, the album Load showed a bit more craftsmanship with the songs, and little more melodic consideration. The opening song from ReLoad was used at the beginning of NASCAR broadcasts for years, so it can't be that metal. But still, they kept those metal elements through their albums, even in a live show with the San Francisco Symphony! Let's hear some songs:
 
...And Justice for All
 
Links to an external site.
 
One
 
Links to an external site.
 
Nothing Else Matters
 
Links to an external site.
 
The Unforgiven
 
Links to an external site.
 
Enter Sandman
 
Links to an external site.


Hero of the Day


Links to an external site. (from Load. The intro is quite restrained)
'''Metallica'''


Whisky in the Jar
Metallica is the archetypal heavy metal band of the mid 1980-s and 1990s. They achieved success with 1988s ''...And Justice for All''. They definitely took metal to harder extremes from previous bands, but also ended up softening up a tiny little as they got older with ''Load'' and ''ReLoad'', then got a bit more metal again with ''St. Anger''. The album ''Load'' showed a bit more craftsmanship with the songs, and little more melodic consideration. The opening song from ''ReLoad'' was used at the beginning of NASCAR broadcasts for years, so it can't be that metal. But still, they kept those metal elements through their albums, even in a live show with the San Francisco Symphony! Let's hear some songs:


Links to an external site. (old irish folk song)
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/0ep7UTGw3F9VkN9FV52En3?si=5a116537dbce40be ...And Justice for All]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/0LAcM6I7ijW4VVW0aytl1t?si=8188d9b603d74cec One]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/2CtemffYhT0DJWcT1XW047?si=10f3f20a6a5d4f4a Nothing Else Matters]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/7lwvxYumAEo10lzAplRGXM?si=9c2d0bbedc0e4837 The Unforgiven]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3VqHuw0wFlIHcIPWkhIbdQ?si=32b47e50aec84413 Enter Sandman]
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/5ktyEZbrgBEePsu6MW5Cvw?si=97f0020fb77947f8 Hero of the Day] - from Load. The intro is quite restrained, but it builds to a double-kick drum head-banging chorus.
* [https://open.spotify.com/track/3ZpWy5rBZv2aLQAldnmTsP?si=f8cc49a85dfb4ee3 Whisky in the Jar] - old irish folk song, done Metallica style.


That's all I have for this post. I could go on, but we'd have a million listening examples. Bands left out of this post: Motley Crue, Twisted Sister, W.A.S.P., Quiet Riot, Queensryche, Ratt, Stained, Slipknot, Megadeath, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Whitesnake, Def Leppard, and more. The follow up post will deal with the metal fragments of thrash metal, speed metal, death metal, and nü metal.
This post could go on, but we'd have a million listening examples. Bands left out of this post: Motley Crue, Twisted Sister, W.A.S.P., Quiet Riot, Queensryche, Ratt, Stained, Slipknot, Megadeath, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Whitesnake, Def Leppard, and more. This post also needs to deal with the metal fragmentation into thrash metal, speed metal, death metal, and nü metal.

Latest revision as of 13:37, 21 September 2024

Link to Spotify playlist: Mus115 - 13. Metal



Metal overview: to a lot of fans, Heavy Metal is a changeable term. Early Metal bands no longer qualify with our current understanding of Heavy Metal. But broadly speaking, Metal is louder, and "harder" (i.e., more distortion in the guitars, vocals, louder drums, more complications in rhythms, faster playing, repetitive riffs) and, lyrically, about hard topics like violence, suicide, rebellion, and anger. Basically rock with the soft edges removed.

Quasi-Metal

One of the first bands that started this or at least influenced many of the real metal bands to follow was Led Zeppelin. There is constant debate regarding if Led Zeppelin is actually metal or not. This is something to consider in the questions. Elements such as high-pitched vocal bordering on shouting, with lots of edge, heavy low-range guitar, lots of 16th note subdivisions, are definitely characteristics of metal, and can be found in 3 of the following 4 songs:

Their biggest hit is the least "metal" one of all:

  • Stairway to Heaven - a masterpiece of a song. It has a continual crescendo (getting louder) and accelerando (getting faster), which is a bit unusual. Most songs stay at about the same tempo, and while dynamic contrast is more prevalent, they generally don't build continually.


Metal

Black Sabbath and Ozzy Osbourne

After Ozzy split from Black Sabbath, he had great commercial success with hits like:

In particular, Rock 'n' Roll Rebel is probably the most "metal" of these. Lyrically, we can see a great example of the metal ethos. Whereas Bob Dylan wrote "please get out of the new [road] / If you can't lend a hand" in his song "The Times, They Are a Changin' ", Ozzy wrote "Do what you will to try and make me conform / But I'll make you wish you had never been born". Yikes!

American Metal

I'm skipping some bands like Steppenwolf and MC5, and straight to Alice Cooper.

Each successive metal act tried to "out metal" the previous. Alice Cooper is the name of the band as well as the stage name of the singer, and they created a stage show that had bits of violence, the occult, sadomasochism, and (unfortunately) animal abuse. They would throw live chickens to the crowd who would rip them to shreds. This was a band who wasn't really getting anywhere until the notoriety of the stage antics put them on the map.

Some hits:


Van Halen

Another example of a band where today, the songs don't seem metal at all (and fit more in 90s alternative style possibly), but at the time, they were absolutely considered metal. They hit big with singer David Lee Roth from 1983 - 1986, and had continued success with Sammy Hagar in 1986-1996. This is a hot topic divide for some Van Halen fans - some consider the David Lee Roth Era as the "only" era, while others like Sammy better. One of the main things with the band is that Eddie Van Halen became the real star, with the release of "Eruption", a guitar only instrumental that featured double-tapping technique. This was not a new technique. In fact, I think there was video of Chuck Berry doing a little bit in his shows. But it was certainly the first to highlight, magnify, and popularize this technique. If you're not sure what this means, here's an explanation video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWAi39zz1G0

Of course, one of Van Halen's biggest hits (especially in the Sammy Hagar years) is probably this song:

The video ended up winning the MTV "Video of the Year" award in 1992 (when it was released). Here's a behind the scenes article about the creation and the video:


Guns N' Roses

and a rare acoustic, softer side:


Metallica

Metallica is the archetypal heavy metal band of the mid 1980-s and 1990s. They achieved success with 1988s ...And Justice for All. They definitely took metal to harder extremes from previous bands, but also ended up softening up a tiny little as they got older with Load and ReLoad, then got a bit more metal again with St. Anger. The album Load showed a bit more craftsmanship with the songs, and little more melodic consideration. The opening song from ReLoad was used at the beginning of NASCAR broadcasts for years, so it can't be that metal. But still, they kept those metal elements through their albums, even in a live show with the San Francisco Symphony! Let's hear some songs:

This post could go on, but we'd have a million listening examples. Bands left out of this post: Motley Crue, Twisted Sister, W.A.S.P., Quiet Riot, Queensryche, Ratt, Stained, Slipknot, Megadeath, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest, Whitesnake, Def Leppard, and more. This post also needs to deal with the metal fragmentation into thrash metal, speed metal, death metal, and nü metal.